PASTORALISM
A
catt of the Bakhtiari people, Chaharmahal and Bakhtiari Province,
Iran
Livestock
market in Mali
Pastoralism
is a form of animal husbandry where domesticated animals known as
livestock are released onto large vegetated outdoor lands (pastures)
for grazing, historically by nomadic people who moved around with
their herds. The species involved include cattle, camels, goats,
yaks, llamas, reindeer, horse and sheep.
Pastoralism
is found in many variations throughout the world, generally where
environmental characteristics such as aridity, poor soils, cold
or hot temperature, and lack of water make crop growing difficult
or impossible. Operating in these more extreme environments with
more marginal lands, mean that pastoral communities are very vulnerable
to global warming.
Pastoralism
remains a way of life in many geographies including Africa, the
Tibetan plateau, the Eurasian steppes, the Andes, Patagonia, the
Pampas, Australia and many other places. As of 2019, 200-500 million
people practise pastoralism globally, and 75% of all countries have
pastoral communities.
Pastoral
communities have different levels of mobility. Sedentary pastoralism
is becoming more common as the hardening of political borders, land
tenures, expansion of crop farming, and construction of fences and
dedicated agricultural buildings all reduce the ability to move
livestocks around freely, leading to the rise of pastoral farming
on established grazing zones called ranches. Sedentary pastoralists
might also raise crops and livestocks together in the form of mixed
farming, for the purpose of diversifying productivity, obtaining
manure for organic farming, and improve pasture conditions for their
livestock. Mobile pastoralism includes moving herds locally across
short distances in search of fresh forage and water, something that
can occur daily or even within a few hours; to transhumance, where
animals are routinely moved between different seasonal pastures
across regions; to nomadism, where pastoralists and families move
with the animals in search for any available grazing grounds without
much long-term planning. Grazing in woodlands and forests may be
referred to as silvopastoralism.
Pastoralist
herds interact with their environment, and mediate human relations
with the environment as a way of turning uncultivated plants like
wild grass into food. In many places, grazing herds on savannas
and woodlands can help maintain the biodiversity of the savannas
and prevent them from evolving into dense shrublands or forests.
Grazing and browsing at the appropriate levels often can increase
biodiversity in Mediterranean climate regions. Pastoralists shape
ecosystems in different ways: some communities use fire to make
ecosystems more suitable for grazing and browsing animals.
Origins
:
Khoikhoi
dismantling their huts, preparing to move to new pastures. Aquatint
by Samuel Daniell (1805)
One theory is that pastoralism was created from mixed farming. Bates
and Lees proposed that it was the incorporation of irrigation into
farming which ensued in specialization. Advantages of mixed farming
include reducing risk of failure, spreading labour, and re-utilizing
resources. The importance of these advantages and disadvantages
to different farmers differs according to the sociocultural preferences
of the farmers and the biophysical conditions as determined by rainfall,
radiation, soil type, and disease. The increased productivity of
irrigation agriculture led to an increase in population and an added
impact on resources. Bordering areas of land remained in use for
animal breeding. This meant that large distances had to be covered
by herds to collect sufficient forage. Specialization occurred as
a result of the increasing importance of both intensive agriculture
and pastoralism. Both agriculture and pastoralism developed alongside
each other, with continuous interactions.
There
is another theory that suggests pastoralism evolved from hunting
and gathering. Hunters of wild goats and sheep were knowledgeable
about herd mobility and the needs of the animals. Such hunters were
mobile and followed the herds on their seasonal rounds. Undomesticated
herds were chosen to become more controllable for the proto-pastoralist
nomadic hunter and gatherer groups by taming and domesticating them.
Hunter-gatherers' strategies in the past have been very diverse
and contingent upon the local environment conditions, like those
of mixed farmers. Foraging strategies have included hunting or trapping
big game and smaller animals, fishing, collecting shellfish or insects,
and gathering wild plant foods such as fruits, seeds, and nuts.
These diverse strategies for survival amongst the migratory herds
could also provide an evolutionary route towards nomadic pastoralism.
Resources
:
Pastoralism occurs in uncultivated areas. Wild animals eat the forage
from the marginal lands and humans survive from milk, blood, and
often meat of the herds and often trade by-products like wool and
milk for money and food.
Pastoralists
do not exist at basic subsistence. Pastoralists often compile wealth
and participate in international trade. Pastoralists have trade
relations with agriculturalists, horticulturalists, and other groups.
Pastoralists are not extensively dependent on milk, blood, and meat
of their herd. McCabe noted that when common property institutions
are created, in long-lived communities, resource sustainability
is much higher, which is evident in the East African grasslands
of pastoralist populations. However, it needs to be noted that the
property rights structure is only one of the many different parameters
that affect the sustainability of resources, and common or private
property per se, does not necessarily lead to sustainability.
Global map of pastoralism, origins and spread, from
Some pastoralists supplement herding with hunting and gathering,
fishing and/or small-scale farming or pastoral farming.
Mobility
:
Mongol
pastoralist in the Khövsgöl Province
Mobility allows pastoralists to adapt to the environment, which
opens up the possibility for both fertile and infertile regions
to support human existence. Important components of pastoralism
include low population density, mobility, vitality, and intricate
information systems. The system is transformed to fit the environment
rather than adjusting the environment to support the "food
production system." Mobile pastoralists can often cover a radius
of a hundred to five hundred kilometers.
Pastoralists
and their livestock have impacted the environment. Lands long used
for pastoralism have transformed under the forces of grazing livestock
and anthropogenic fire. Fire was a method of revitalizing pastureland
and preventing forest regrowth. The collective environmental weights
of fire and livestock browsing have transformed landscapes in many
parts of the world. Fire has permitted pastoralists to tend the
land for their livestock. Political boundaries are based on environmental
boundaries. The Maquis shrublands of the Mediterranean region are
dominated by pyrophytic plants that thrive under conditions of anthropogenic
fire and livestock grazing.
Nomadic
pastoralists have a global food-producing strategy depending on
the management of herd animals for meat, skin, wool, milk, blood,
manure, and transport. Nomadic pastoralism is practiced in different
climates and environments with daily movement and seasonal migration.
Pastoralists are among the most flexible populations. Pastoralist
societies have had field armed men protect their livestock and their
people and then to return into a disorganized pattern of foraging.
The products of the herd animals are the most important resources,
although the use of other resources, including domesticated and
wild plants, hunted animals, and goods accessible in a market economy
are not excluded. The boundaries between states impact the viability
of subsistence and trade relations with cultivators.
Pastoralist
strategies typify effective adaptation to the environment. Precipitation
differences are evaluated by pastoralists. In East Africa, different
animals are taken to specific regions throughout the year that corresponds
to the seasonal patterns of precipitation. Transhumance is the seasonal
migration of livestock and pastoralists between higher and lower
pastures.
Some
pastoralists are constantly moving, which may put them at odds with
sedentary people of towns and cities. The resulting conflicts can
result in war for disputed lands. These disputes are recorded in
ancient times in the Middle East, as well as for East Asia. Other
pastoralists are able to remain in the same location which results
in longer-standing housing.
Camel market in Sudan
Different mobility patterns can be observed: Somali pastoralists
keep their animals in one of the harshest environments but they
have evolved of the centuries. Somalis have well developed pastoral
culture where complete system of life and governance has been refined.
Somali poetry depicts humans interactions, pastoral animals, beasts
on the prowl, and other natural things such the rain, celestial
events and historic events of significance.
Mobility
was an important strategy for the Ariaal; however with the loss
of grazing land impacted by the growth in population, severe drought,
the expansion of agriculture, and the expansion of commercial ranches
and game parks, mobility was lost. The poorest families were driven
out of pastoralism and into towns to take jobs. Few Ariaal families
benefited from education, healthcare, and income earning.
The
flexibility of pastoralists to respond to environmental change was
reduced by colonization. For example, mobility was limited in the
Sahel region of Africa with settlement being encouraged. The population
tripled and sanitation and medical treatment were improved.
The
Afar pastoralists in Ethiopia uses an indigenous communication method
called dagu for information. This helps them in getting crucial
information about climate and availability of pastures at various
locations.
Information
:
Pastoralists have mental maps of the value of specific environments
at different times of year. Pastoralists have an understanding of
ecological processes and the environment. Information sharing is
vital for creating knowledge through the networks of linked societies.
Pastoralists
produce food in the world's harshest environments, and pastoral
production supports the livelihoods of rural populations on almost
half of the world's land. Several hundred million people are pastoralists,
mostly in Africa and Asia. ReliefWeb reported that "Several
hundred million people practice pastoralism—the use of extensive
grazing on rangelands for livestock production, in over 100 countries
worldwide. The African Union estimated that Africa has about 268
million pastoralists—over a quarter of the total population—living
on about 43 percent of the continent’s total land mass."
Pastoralists manage rangelands covering about a third of the Earth's
terrestrial surface and are able to produce food where crop production
is not possible.
Nenets reindeer herders in Russia
Pastoralism has been shown, "based on a review of many studies,
to be between 2 and 10 times more productive per unit of land than
the capital intensive alternatives that have been put forward".
However, many of these benefits go unmeasured and are frequently
squandered by policies and investments that seek to replace pastoralism
with more capital intensive modes of production. They have traditionally
suffered from poor understanding, marginalization and exclusion
from dialogue. The Pastoralist Knowledge Hub, managed by the Food
and Agriculture Organization of the UN serves as a knowledge repository
on technical excellence on pastoralism as well as "a neutral
forum for exchange and alliance building among pastoralists and
stakeholders working on pastoralist issues".
Pastoralism
and farm animal genetic resource :
There is a variation in genetic makeup of the farm animals driven
mainly by natural and human based selection.For example, pastoralists
in large parts of Sub Saharan Africa are preferring livestock breeds
which are adapted to their environment and able to tolerate drought
and diseases. However, in other animal production systems these
breeds are discouraged and more productive exotic ones are favored.
This situation could not be left unaddressed due to the changes
in market preferences and climate all over the world, which could
lead to changes in livestock diseases occurrence and decline forage
quality and availability. Hence pastoralists can maintain farm animal
genetic resources by conserving local livestock breeds. Generally
conserving farm animal genetic resources under pastoralism is advantageous
in terms of reliability and associated cost.
Tragedy
of the commons :
Hardin's Tragedy of the Commons (1968) described how common property
resources, such as the land shared by pastoralists, eventually become
overused and ruined. According to Hardin's paper, the pastoralist
land use strategy suffered criticisms of being unstable and a cause
of environmental degradation.
Tuareg pastoralists and their herds flee south into Nigeria
from Niger during the 2005–06 Niger food crisis
However, one of Hardin's conditions for a "tragedy of the commons"
is that people cannot communicate with each other or make agreements
and contracts. Many scholars have pointed out that this is ridiculous,
and yet it is applied in development projects around the globe,
motivating the destruction of community and other governance systems
that have managed sustainable pastoral systems for thousands of
years. The outcomes have often been disastrous. In her book Governing
the Commons, Elinor Ostrom showed that communities were not trapped
and helpless amid diminishing commons. She argued that a Common-pool
resource, such as grazing lands used for pastoralism, can be managed
more sustainably through community groups and cooperatives than
through privatization or total governmental control. Ostrom was
awarded a Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences for her work.
Pastoralists
in the Sahel zone in Africa were held responsible for the depletion
of resources. The depletion of resources was actually triggered
by a prior interference and punitive climate conditions. Hardin's
paper suggests a solution to the problems, offering a coherent basis
for privatization of land, which stimulates the transfer of land
from tribal peoples to the state or to individuals. The privatized
programs impact the livelihood of the pastoralist societies while
weakening the environment. Settlement programs often serve the needs
of the state in reducing the autonomy and livelihoods of pastoral
people.
The
violent herder–farmer conflicts in Nigeria, Mali, Sudan, Ethiopia
and other countries in the Sahel and Horn of Africa regions have
been exacerbated by climate change, land degradation, and population
growth.
However,
recently it has been shown that pastoralism supports human existence
in harsh environments and often represents a sustainable approach
to land use.
Source
:
https://en.wikipedia.org/
wiki/Pastoralism