TOCHARIANS
Probable
Tocharian donors, from the Kizilgaha caves near Kucha, 6th century
AD. They appear Europoid, and have Sasanian-style dress. These paintings
are associated with annotations in Tocharian and Sanskrit made by
their painters.
Regions
with significant populations : Tarim Basin in 1st millennium
AD (modern Xinjiang, China)
Languages : Tocharian languages
Religion : Buddhism and others
Related ethnic groups : Indo-Iranians, Afanasievo and BMAC
culture
The
Tocharians, or Tokharians, were speakers of Tocharian languages,
Indo-European languages known from around 7600 documents from around
400 to 1200 AD, found on the northern edge of the Tarim Basin (modern
Xinjiang, China). The name "Tocharian" was given to these
languages in the early 20th century by scholars who identified their
speakers with a people known in ancient Greek sources as the Tókharoi
(Latin Tochari), who inhabited Bactria from the 2nd century BC.
This identification is generally considered erroneous, but the name
"Tocharian" remains the most common term for the languages
and their speakers. Their actual ethnic name is unknown, although
they may have referred to themselves as Agni, Kuci and Krorän,
or Agniya, Kuchiya as known from Sanskrit texts.
Agricultural
communities first appeared in the oases of the northern Tarim circa
2000 BC. (The earliest Tarim mummies, which may not be connected
to the Tocharians, date from c. 1800 BC.) Some scholars have linked
these communities to the Afanasievo culture found earlier (c. 3500–2500
BC) in Siberia, north of the Tarim or Central Asian BMAC culture.
By
the 2nd century BC, these settlements had developed into city-states,
overshadowed by nomadic peoples to the north and Chinese empires
to the east. These cities, the largest of which was Kucha, also
served as way stations on the branch of the Silk Road that ran along
the northern edge of the Taklamakan desert.
From
the 8th century AD, the Uyghurs – speakers of a Turkic language
from the Kingdom of Qocho – settled in the region. The peoples
of the Tarim city-states intermixed with the Uyghurs, whose Old
Uyghur language spread through the region. The Tocharian languages
are believed to have become extinct during the 9th century.
Names
:
Around the beginning of the 20th century, archaeologists recovered
a number of manuscripts from oases in the Tarim Basin written in
two closely related but previously unknown Indo-European languages,
which were easy to read because they used a close variation of the
already deciphered Indian Middle-Brahmi script. These languages
were designated in similar fashion by their geographical neighbours
:
•
A Buddhist work
in Old Turkic (Uighur), included a colophon stating that the text
had been translated from Sanskrit via toxrï tyly ("The
language of the Togari").
• Manichean
texts in several languages of neighbouring regions used the expression
"the land of the Four Toghar" to designate the area "from
Kucha and Karashar to Kocho [disambiguation needed] and Beshbalik.
Friedrich W. K. Müller was the first to propose a characterization
for the newly discovered languages. Müller called the languages
"Tocharian" (German Tocharisch), linking this toxrï
("Togari") with the ethnonym Tókharoi applied by
Strabo to one of the "Scythian" tribes "from the
country on the other side of the Iaxartes" that overran the
Greco-Bactrian kingdom (present day Afghanistan-Pakistan) in the
second half of the 2nd century BC. This term also appears in Indo-Iranian
languages (Sanskrit Tushar/Tukhar, Old Persian tuxari-, Khotanese
ttahvara), and became the source of the term "Tokharistan"
usually referring to 1st millennium Bactria, as well as the Takhar
province of Afghanistan. The Tókharoi are often identified
by modern scholars with the Yuezhi of Chinese historical accounts,
who founded the Kushan Empire.
Müller's
identification became a minority position among scholars when it
turned out that the people of Tokharistan (Bactria) spoke Bactrian,
an Eastern Iranian language, which is quite distinct from the Tocharian
languages. Nevertheless, "Tocharian" remained the standard
term for the languages of the Tarim Basin manuscripts and for the
people who produced them. A few scholars still affirm that the "Tocharians"
and the Yuezhi are identical, attributing the Bactrian language
of the Yuezhi to a later adoption.
The
name of Kucha in Tocharian B was Kusi, with adjectival form kusiññe.
The word may be derived from Proto-Indo-European *keuk "shining,
white". The Tocharian B word akeññe may have
referred to people of Agni, with a derivation meaning "borderers,
marchers". One of the Tocharian A texts has arsi-käntwa
as a name for their own language, so that arsi may have meant "Agnean",
though "monk" is also possible.
Languages
:
The geographical spread of the Indo-European languages
The
Tocharian script is very similar to the Indian Brahmi script from
the Kushan period. Tocharian language inscription: Se pañäkte
sanketavattse sarsa papaiykau "This Buddha was painted by the
hand of Sanketav", on a painting carbon dated to 245-340 AD.
The Tocharian languages are known from around 7600 documents dating
from about 400 to 1200 AD, found at 30 sites in the northeast Tarim
area. The manuscripts are written in two distinct, but closely related,
Indo-European languages, conventionally known as Tocharian A and
Tocharian B.
Tocharian
A (Agnean or East Tocharian) was found in the northeastern oases
known to the Tocharians as Arsi, later Agni (i.e. Chinese Yanqi;
modern Karasahr) and Turpan (including Khocho or Qoco; known in
Chinese as Gaochang). Some 500 manuscripts have been studied in
detail, mostly coming from Buddhist monasteries. Many authors take
this to imply that Tocharian A had become a purely literary and
liturgical language by the time of the manuscripts, but it may be
that the surviving documents are unrepresentative.
Tocharian
B (Kuchean or West Tocharian) was found at all the Tocharian A sites
and also in several sites further west, including Kuchi (later Kucha).
It appears to have still been in use in daily life at that time.
Over 3200 manuscripts have been studied in detail.
The
languages had significant differences in phonology, morphology and
vocabulary, making them mutually unintelligible "at least as
much as modern Germanic or Romance languages". Tocharian A
shows innovations in the vowels and nominal inflection, whereas
Tocharian B has changes in the consonants and verbal inflection.
Many of the differences in vocabulary between the languages concern
Buddhist concepts, which may suggest that they were associated with
different Buddhist traditions.
The
differences indicate that they diverged from a common ancestor between
500 and 1000 years before the earliest documents, that is, some
time in the 1st millennium BC. Common Indo-European vocabulary retained
in Tocharian includes words for herding, cattle, sheep, pigs, dogs,
horses, textiles, farming, wheat, gold, silver, and wheeled vehicles.
Prakrit
documents from 3rd century Krorän, Andir and Niya on the southeast
edge of the Tarim Basin contain around 100 loanwords and 1000 proper
names that cannot be traced to an Indic or Iranian source. Thomas
Burrow suggested that they come from a variety of Tocharian, dubbed
Tocharian C or Kroränian, which may have been spoken by at
least some of the local populace. Burrow's theory is widely accepted,
but the evidence is meagre and inconclusive, and some scholars favour
alternative explanations.
Origins
:
Migration of Yamnaya culture people, and location of the
Afanasievo culture and their probable Tocharians descendants
J. P. Mallory and Victor H. Mair argue that the Tarim was first
settled by Proto-Tocharian-speakers from the Afanasevo culture to
the north, who migrated to the south and occupied the northern and
eastern edges of the Tarim Basin. The Afanasevo culture itself resulted
from the eastward migration of the Yamnaya culture, originally based
in the Pontic steppe north of the Caucasus Mountains. The Afanasevo
culture (c. 3500–2500 BC) displays cultural and genetic connections
with the Indo-European-associated cultures of the Central Asian
steppe yet predates the specifically Indo-Iranian-associated Andronovo
culture (c. 2000–900 BC). The early eastward expansion of
the Yamnaya culture circa 3300 BC is enough to account for the isolation
of the Tocharian languages from Indo-Iranian linguistic innovations
like satemization.
Settlement
of the Tarim basin :
The Taklamakan Desert is roughly oval in shape, about 1,000 km long
and 400 km wide, surrounded on three sides by high mountains. The
main part of the desert is sandy, surrounded by a belt of gravel
desert. The desert is completely barren, but in the late spring
the melting snows of the surrounding mountains feed streams, which
have been altered by human activity to create oases with mild microclimates
and supporting intensive agriculture. On the northern edge of the
basin, these oases occur in small valleys before the gravels. On
the southern edge, they occur in alluvial fans on the edge of the
sand zone. Isolated alluvial fan oases also occur in the gravel
deserts of the Turpan Depression to the east of the Taklamakan.
From around 2000 BC, these oases supported Bronze Age settled agricultural
communities of steadily increasing sophistication.
The
necessary irrigation technology was first developed during the 3rd
millennium BC in the Bactria-Margiana Archaeological Complex (BMAC)
to the west of the Pamir mountains, but it is unclear how it reached
the Tarim. The staple crops, wheat and barley, also originated in
the west.
Tarim
mummies :
One
of the Tarim mummies
"Loulan
beauty"
The oldest of the Tarim mummies, bodies preserved by the desert
conditions, date from 2000 BC and were found on the eastern edge
of the Tarim basin. They seem to be Caucasoid types with light-colored
hair. A genetic study of remains from the oldest layer of the Xiaohe
Cemetery found that the maternal lineages were a mixture of east
and west Eurasian types, while all the paternal lineages were of
west Eurasian type. It is unknown whether they are connected with
the frescoes painted at Tocharian sites more than two millennia
later, which also depict light eyes and hair color.
Later,
groups of nomadic pastoralists moved from the steppe into the grasslands
to the north and northeast of the Tarim. They were the ancestors
of peoples later known to Chinese authors as the Wusun and Yuezhi.
At least some of them spoke Iranian languages, but a minority of
scholars suggest that the Yuezhi were Tocharian speakers.
During
the 1st millennium BC, a further wave of immigrants, the Saka speaking
Iranian languages, arrived from the west and settled along the southern
rim of the Tarim. They are believed to be the source of Iranian
loanwords in Tocharian languages, particularly related to commerce
and warfare.
Religion
:
Most Tocharian inscriptions are from Buddhist monastical texts,
suggesting that Tocharians largely embraced this religion. Pre-Buddhist
beliefs are largely unknown, but several Chinese goddesses are similar
to those of the speculated Proto-Indo-European sun goddess and the
dawn goddess, implying influence from them through trade routes
in Tocharian territories and therefore their worship there. Tocharian
B has a noun swañco derived from the name of the Proto-Indo-European
sun goddess, while Tocharian A has kom, a loanword etymologically
connected to the Turkic sun goddess Gun Ana. Besides this, they
might have also worshipped a lunar deity (meñ-) and an earth
one (kem-).
Oasis
states :
Major
oasis states of the ancient Tarim Basin
The first record of the oasis states is found in Chinese histories.
The Book of Han lists 36 statelets in the Tarim basin in the last
two centuries BC. These oases served as waystations on the trade
routes forming part of the Silk Road passing along the northern
and southern edges of the Taklamakan desert. The largest were Kucha
with 81,000 inhabitants and Agni (Yanqi or Karashar) with 32,000.
Chinese histories give no evidence of ethnic changes in these cities
between that time and the period of the Tocharian manuscripts from
these sites. Situated on the northern edge of the Tarim, these small
urban societies were overshadowed by nomadic peoples to the north
and Chinese empires to the east. They conceded tributary relations
with the larger powers when required, and acted independently when
they could.
Xiongnu
and Han empire :
In 177 BC, the Xiongnu drove the Yuezhi from western Gansu, causing
most of them to flee west to the Ili Valley and then to Bactria.
The Xiongnu then overcame the Tarim statelets, which became a vital
part of their empire. The Chinese Han dynasty was determined to
weaken their Xiongnu enemies by depriving them of this area. This
was achieved in a series of campaigns beginning in 108 BC and culminating
in the establishment of the Protectorate of the Western Regions
in 60 BC under Zheng Ji. The Han government used a range of tactics,
including plots to assassinate local rulers, direct attacks on a
few states (e.g. Kucha in 65 BC) to cow the rest, and the massacre
of the entire population of Luntai (80 km east of Kucha) when they
resisted. The Han controlled the Tarim states intermittently until
their final withdrawal in 150 AD.
Flourishing
of the oasis states :
Kucha, the largest of the oasis cities, was ruled by the Bai family,
sometimes autonomously and sometimes as vassals of outside powers.
The government included some 30 named posts below the king, with
all but the highest-ranking titles occurring in pairs of left and
right. Other states had similar structures, though on a smaller
scale. The Book of Jin says of the city :
They
have a walled city and suburbs. The walls are threefold. Within
are Buddhist temples and stupas numbering a thousand. The people
are engaged in agriculture and husbandry. The men and women cut
their hair and wear it at the neck. The prince's palace is grand
and imposing, glittering like an abode of the gods.
—
Book of Jin, Chapter 97
The inhabitants grew red millet, wheat, rice, legumes, hemp, grapes
and pomegranates, and reared horses, cattle, sheep and camels. They
also extracted a wide range of metals and minerals from the surrounding
mountains.Handicrafts included leather goods, fine felts and rugs.
Kushan
Empire (2nd century AD) :
A
bronze coin of Kanishka the Great found in Khotan, Tarim Basin.
2nd century AD
Kizil
Caves paintings in Gandhar style, with Tocharian inscriptions. Carbon
dated to 245 - 340 CE
The Kushan Empire expanded into the Tarim during the 2nd century
AD, bringing Buddhism, Kushan art, Sanskrit as a liturgical language
and Prakrit as an administrative language (in the southern Tarim
states). With these Indic languages came scripts, including the
Brahmi script (later adapted to write Tocharian) and the Kharosthi
script.
From
the 3rd century, Kucha became a centre of Buddhist studies. Buddhist
texts were translated into Chinese by Kuchean monks, the most famous
of whom was Kumarajiva (344–412/5). Captured by Lü Guang
of the Later Liang in an attack on Kucha in 384, Kumarajiva learned
Chinese during his years of captivity in Gansu. In 401, he was brought
to the Later Qin capital of Chang'an, where he remained as head
of a translation bureau until his death in 413.
The
Kizil Caves lie 65 km west of Kucha, and contain over 236 Buddhist
temples. Their murals date from the 3rd to the 8th century. Many
of these murals were removed by Albert von Le Coq and other European
archaeologists in the early 20th century, and are now held in European
museums, but others remain in their original locations.
An
increasingly dry climate in the 4th and 5th centuries led to the
abandonment of several of the southern cities, including Niya and
Krorän, with a consequent shift of trade from the southern
route to the northern one.Confederations of nomadic tribes also
began to jostle for supremacy. The northern oasis states were conquered
by Rouran in the late 5th century, leaving the local leaders in
place.
Hephthalite
conquest (circa 480 - 550 AD) :
An
early "Tocharian donors" mural, Qizil, Tarim Basin. This
painting was carbon dated to 432–538 CE. The style of the
swordsmen in single-lapel caftan is now considered to belong to
the Hephthalites, from Tokharistan, who occupied the Tarim Basin
from 480 to 560 CE, and spoke Bactrian, an Eastern Iranian language.
In the late 5th century CE the Hephthalites, based in Tokharistan
(Bactria), expanded eastward through the Pamir Mountains, which
are comparatively easy to cross, as did the Kushans before them,
due to the presence of convenient plateaus between high peaks. They
occupied the western Tarim Basin (Kashgar and Khotan), taking control
of the area from the Ruanruans, who had been collecting heavy tribute
from the oasis cities, but were now weakening under the assaults
of the Chinese Wei Dynasty. In 479 they took the east end of the
Tarim Basin, around the region of Turfan. In 497–509, they
pushed north of Turfan to the Urumchi region. In the early years
of the 6th century, they were sending embassies from their dominions
in the Tarim Basin to the Wei Dynasty. The Hephthalites continued
to occupy the Tarim Basin until the end of their Empire, circa 560
CE.
As
the territories ruled by the Hephthalites expanded into Central
Asia and the Tarim Basin, the art of the Hephthalites, with characteristic
clothing and hairstyles, also came to be used in the areas they
ruled, such as Sogdiana, Bamiyan or Kucha in the Tarim Basin (Kizil
Caves, Kumtura Caves, Subashi reliquary). In these areas appear
dignitaries with caftans with a triangular collar on the right side,
crowns with three crescents, some crowns with wings, and a unique
hairstyle. Another marker is the two-point suspension system for
swords, which seems to have been an Hephthalite innovation, and
was introduced by them in the territories they controled. The paintings
from the Kucha region, particularly the swordmen in the Kizil Caves,
appear to have been made during Hephthalite rule in the region,
circa 480–550 CE. The influence of the art of Gandhar in some
of the earliest paintings at the Kizil Caves, dated to circa 500
CE, is considered as a consequence of the political unification
of the area between Bactria and Kucha under the Hephthalites.
Göktürks
:
Wooden
tablet describing a piece of land, Kucha, 6th – 7th century
The early Turks of the First Turkic Khaganate then took control
of the Turfan and Kucha areas from around 560 CE, and, in alliance
with the Sasanian Empire, became instrumental in the fall of the
Hepthalite Empire.
The
Turks then split into western and eastern khaganates. The Bai family
continued to rule Kucha, as vassals of the Western Turks. Many surviving
texts in Tocharian date from this period, and deal with a wide variety
of administrative, religious and everyday topics. They also include
travel passes, small slips of poplar wood giving the size of the
permitted caravans for officials at the next station along the road.
Tang
conquest and aftermath :
In the 7th century, Emperor Taizong of Tang China, having overcome
the Eastern Turks, sent his armies west to attack the Western Turks
and the oasis states. The first oasis to fall was Turfan, which
was captured in 630 and annexed as part of China.
Emperor Taizong's campaign against the oasis states
Next to the west lay the city of Agni, which had been a tributary
of the Tang since 632. Alarmed by the nearby Chinese armies, Agni
stopped sending Tribute to China and formed an alliance with the
Western Turks. They were aided by Kucha, who also stopped sending
tribute. The Tang captured Agni in 644, defeating a Western Turk
relief force, and made the king resume tribute. When that king was
deposed by a relative in 648, the Tang sent an army under the Turk
general Ashina She'er to install a compliant member of the local
royal family. Ashina She'er continued to capture Kucha, and made
it the headquarters of the Tang Protectorate General to Pacify the
West. Kuchean forces recaptured the city and killed protector-general,
Guo Xiaoke, but it fell again to Ashina She'er, who had 11,000 of
the inhabitants executed in reprisal for the killing of Guo. The
Tocharian cities never recovered from the Tang conquest.
The
Tang lost the Tarim basin to the Tibetan Empire in 670, but regained
it in 692, and continued to rule there until it was recaptured by
the Tibetans in 792. The ruling Bai family of Kucha are last mentioned
in Chinese sources in 787. There is little mention of the region
in Chinese sources for the 9th and 10th centuries.
The
Uyghur Khaganate took control of the northern Tarim in 803. After
their capital in Mongolia was sacked by the Yenisei Kyrgyz in 840,
they established a new state, the Kingdom of Qocho with its capital
at Gaochang (near Turfan) in 866. Over centuries of contact and
intermarriage, the cultures and populations of the pastoralist rulers
and their agriculturalist subjects blended together. The Uighurs
abandoned their state religion of Manichaeism in favour of Buddhism,
and adopted the agricultural lifestyle and many of the customs of
the oasis-dwellers. The Tocharian language gradually disappeared
as the urban population switched to the Old Uyghur language.
Source
:
https://en.wikipedia.org/
wiki/Tocharians